FINANCIAL PLANNING : A Reality Check

Money isn’t everything, but having control and confidence about how you are managing it can allow you to concentrate on other things like your family, your career, and your future. We believe that all your dreams are achievable and we look to partnering you so that you can live your dreams!

Monday, 16 June 2008

To pay or not to pay – is that your question?

Fee-based financial planning service is still new to this country. Though there are firms and individuals who charge for their advice, the number is still very small. Investors often wonder, as to why they should pay a fee when they can get the same advice for ‘free’. Is that really so? Is that ‘free’ advice in your interest?

Let me explain this point through an incident. Some time back, a senior executive of a BPO firm had called me to discuss his financial plans. When I told him that I charge a fee for my services, his facial expression changed. “I’ll get back to you.” He curtly told me. I realized what that meant and why he had said that.

I decided to try and reason it out with him. I pointed out to the two insurance policies that he had taken a year back. Till we started the discussion, he did not even know the name of the policies he had bought nor what kind of policies those were - whether it was a term plan, an endowment policy or a ULIP.

During our discussion, he realized that one of the policies (a ULIP) was not going to be of any use to him in the long-run since he needed the money after 4 years. His ‘advisor’ had told him that he could pay for 3 years and redeem the policy in the 4th year. What he did not tell him was that in the first 3 years almost 40-50% of his premium paid would be charged as fees (for his advisor) and that out of the Rs 3 lakh that he was going to invest over 3 years only Rs 1.50-1.80 lakh was going to be actually invested. (Don’t read me wrong, I am not against ULIPs. ULIPs, as investment products, are suitable over long horizon -- of over 10 years -- but absolutely unsuitable if your investment tenure is going to be short.)

To cut a long story short, he was actually paying a fee of Rs 1.50 lakh over a three year period. Since he was unaware that he actually shelled out that kind of a fee, he didn’t seem to mind it. And just because I asked him for a fee upfront, he was upset about it. (Incidentally, he would be paying me a similar fee for almost 10 years of unbiased advice, for a host of financial products, not just insurance).

Isn’t it better to know upfront the fee you are paying for getting unbiased advice, as compared to paying a huge fee and not having a clue about it? The ‘free’ advice feeling is actually just a misconception. The reality is far divorced from that. As we all know – ‘there are no free lunches’ in life.

Why hesitate in paying up for financial advice? After all, the financial planner is spending considerable time with you to understand your needs, your lifestyle and a host of other parameters in trying to help achieve your financial dreams. He/she is sharing his/her knowledge and expertise.

It’s better to know what you are paying for. If you don’t, you too may get mislead and will have to pay for it quite dearly (both in terms of cash outflow and a wrong product). And you won’t even realize it…till it’s all too late.

2 comments:

Swati said...

Very true.. Good advice for my life long investments mean a lot to me and my family..

Anonymous said...

MJ, you've hit the nail on the head? But I'm not sure whose head? Ethical advisors always end up with a headache when it comes convincing the "great indian middle-class saver" that he can be considerably better off if he pays for professional advice instead of fishing for free tips!